The Buffalo Bills are reportedly planning a surprising move in the 2026 NFL Draft, with analysts predicting they may part ways with star running back James Cook in favor of a versatile, 1,300-yard rusher from Texas, Quintrevion Wisner. This potential shift comes as Cook, a 2022 second-round pick, enters the final year of his rookie contract in 2025, with no extension in sight and tensions brewing over stalled negotiations.
James Cook’s Rise and Contract Standoff
James Cook has been a cornerstone of the Bills’ offense, delivering back-to-back 1,000-yard rushing seasons and tying for the NFL lead with 16 rushing touchdowns in 2024. At just 25 years old, Cook has proven himself a dynamic playmaker, complementing quarterback Josh Allen’s explosive passing game. However, his contract situation has become a point of contention. Cook is reportedly seeking a deal worth around $15-16 million per year, which would place him among the league’s highest-paid running backs, behind only Christian McCaffrey and Saquon Barkley.
The Bills, constrained by salary cap limitations, appear hesitant to commit to such a lucrative extension for a running back, a position increasingly devalued in the NFL. General Manager Brandon Beane has expressed admiration for Cook, calling him a “beautiful man” and a “great dude,” but emphasized the business side of the decision, noting, “Just because we’re not on the same page today doesn’t mean we wouldn’t be tomorrow.” Cook’s absence from voluntary OTAs and his decision to put his Buffalo home on the market have fueled speculation about his dissatisfaction, though insider Ian Rapoport reports Cook will play for the Bills in 2025 despite the impasse.
Enter Quintrevion Wisner: The 1,300-Yard Phenom
With uncertainty surrounding Cook’s future, analysts are eyeing the 2026 NFL Draft as the moment Buffalo pivots to a new running back. In a recent mock draft by Pro Football and Sports Network’s Ian Cummings, the Bills are projected to select Texas running back Quintrevion Wisner in the second round as Cook’s successor.
Wisner, a 6’0”, 200-pound sophomore, burst onto the scene in 2024, amassing 1,064 rushing yards and 311 receiving yards for a total of over 1,300 yards from scrimmage, along with six touchdowns. His combination of elusive instincts, post-contact balance, and pass-catching ability has drawn comparisons to former Texas star Jonathon Brooks. Texas head coach Steve Sarkisian praised Wisner’s natural feel for the game, noting, “He’s tough to get on the ground. He’s physical when he has to be physical. He has speed and real toughness.”
Wisner’s versatility makes him an ideal fit for Buffalo’s offense, which thrives on dynamic playmakers who can contribute both on the ground and through the air. His ability to break tackles and recalibrate after contact adds a unique dimension, potentially filling the void left by Cook’s potential departure.
Why Replace Cook?
The Bills’ financial situation is a key driver behind this potential move. With a tight salary cap and significant investments in players like Josh Allen, extending Cook at his desired price tag could strain the team’s resources. The NFL’s trend of prioritizing cost-effective, draftable running backs over high-priced veterans further supports the idea of letting Cook walk in free agency in 2026.
Moreover, Cook’s limitations in pass protection have been a point of critique. In 2024, he was asked to block on just 11 of his 248 pass snaps, highlighting a weakness that limits his role as an every-down back. Analyst Mike Florio has suggested the Bills are already preparing for life after Cook, urging them to “load another running back in the pipeline.” Wisner, with his well-rounded skill set, could address these shortcomings while providing a cheaper, younger alternative.
The Bigger Picture
The Bills’ potential decision to replace Cook reflects broader NFL trends, where running backs face short shelf lives and teams prioritize financial flexibility. While Cook has been a model of consistency and a fan favorite, the emergence of rookie Ray Davis, who showed promise with 442 yards on 113 carries in 2024, suggests Buffalo is already planning for the future. Drafting Wisner would allow the Bills to maintain their offensive firepower without breaking the bank.
As the 2025 season approaches, all eyes will be on Cook’s performance and whether he can force the Bills’ hand in negotiations. For now, the prospect of Quintrevion Wisner donning the red, white, and blue in 2026 signals a bold new direction for Buffalo’s backfield. Bills fans may be in for a shock, but Wisner’s 1,300-yard pedigree could make the transition a seamless one.