Buffalo Bills running back James Cook is making waves both on and off the field in his fourth NFL season. The 25-year-old star, who has already amassed 355 total yards and four touchdowns through the first three games of the 2025 season, is proving to be a cornerstone of the Bills’ 3-0 start. Coming off a dominant 31-21 Thursday night victory over AFC East rival Miami Dolphins, where Cook rushed for 108 yards and a touchdown on 19 carries, the young running back has solidified his status as one of the league’s premier talents. However, it’s his latest off-field move that has Bills Mafia buzzing with excitement and amusement.
Cook, the younger brother of former NFL star Dalvin Cook, has long been recognized for his on-field prowess. A second-round draft pick out of Georgia in 2022, he has recorded back-to-back 1,000-yard seasons and emerged as a dynamic weapon in the passing game for quarterback Josh Allen. Last season, Cook was the NFL’s co-leader in rushing touchdowns alongside Derrick Henry and Jahmyr Gibbs, earning Pro Bowl honors in both 2023 and 2024. According to FanDuel, he currently holds the 13th-best odds (+3500) to win the NFL Offensive Player of the Year award in 2025. But beyond his athletic achievements, Cook’s latest venture has taken fans by surprise: he now has his very own cookie named after him, dubbed The James Cookie.
Embed X: https://twitter.com/thegreat__4/status/1969548249213386882
As reported by Michael Schwartz of WKBW, Buffalo’s ABC affiliate, The James Cookie is now available at local stores such as Tops, Delta Sonic, and Crosby’s. One local establishment, Brickoven Pizzeria & Pub, proudly showcased the cookie in a detailed Facebook post, describing it as: “A delicious sugar cookie with red, white and blue sprinkles, white chocolate, rice crispies, salted caramel-coated pretzels and toffee crunchies.” The dessert, available for a limited time, has become an instant hit among fans eager to celebrate their star running back in a uniquely Buffalo way.
When Cook shared the post on his social media, Bills Mafia didn’t hold back. Fans flooded the comments with a mix of enthusiasm and humor. One clever fan referenced Cook’s college days at Georgia, where he went by “James Cook III,” joking, “Should of spelled it Cookiii.” Another quipped, “When I think cookies, I think Delta Sonic,” poking fun at the unusual choice of a car wash chain as a cookie retailer. A third fan bestowed a new nickname on the running back: “Cookie Monster,” a moniker that seems destined to stick given Cook’s rising fame and the cookie’s popularity.
Embed X: https://twitter.com/thegreat__4/status/1969548249213386882
The introduction of The James Cookie is more than just a fun marketing move—it’s a testament to Cook’s growing influence in Buffalo and beyond. As the NFL’s leading rusher early in the season (aided by the Bills having played one more game than most teams), Cook’s on-field dominance has made him a fantasy football superstar and a fan favorite. His ability to balance explosive runs with reliable receiving skills has cemented his role as a key component of Buffalo’s high-powered offense, widely regarded as the league’s top team in 2025.
As Bills Mafia continues to rally behind their team’s undefeated start, The James Cookie offers a sweet way for fans to show their support. Whether they’re grabbing one at a local store or joking about Cook’s new “Cookie Monster” persona, the Buffalo faithful are clearly savoring this unexpected treat. With Cook leading the charge on the field and now inspiring baked goods off it, it’s safe to say the Bills running back is leaving his mark in more ways than one.