Skip to main content

Carragher’s Damning Verdict: Chelsea Must CUT BAIT on £80k-p/w ‘Flop’ Compared to John Terry

Chelsea’s transfer window under Todd Boehly has been a wild rollercoaster—part high-octane thrill ride, part gut-wrenching nosedive. They’ve scooped up game-changers like Cole Palmer, Moises Caicedo, Estevao, and Marc Cucurella, turning Stamford Bridge into a hotbed of Premier League fireworks. These studs aren’t just talented; they’re the pulse-pounding future of the squad.

chelsea-premier-league
chelsea-premier-league

But let’s not sugarcoat it: The Blues have also loaded up on more than a few duds, ghosts haunting the payroll who need to be shipped out yesterday. And nowhere has the Boehly blueprint backfired harder than at center-back, where flops have piled up like unpaid parking tickets.

Take Kalidou Koulibaly, the Senegalese wall who crashed into Chelsea like a meteor in 2022 for a cool £33 million from Napoli. On paper? Chef’s kiss. This beast was Europe’s lockdown king, a veteran monster with the resume to anchor any backline. Fans were buzzing—finally, a rock-solid upgrade. But reality hit like a sledgehammer: Koulibaly was a step slow chasing shadows in the Prem, coughing up boneheaded errors left and right. He looked lost, outgunned by the league’s breakneck pace. One forgettable season later? Poof—off to Al-Hilal in Saudi for a paycheck and a prayer. Lesson learned: Don’t buy prime rib when it’s already past its sell-by date.

Then there’s Benoit Badiashile, the towering French prodigy who rolled in from AS Monaco mid-2023 for £35 million. At 6-foot-4, this guy’s billed as the “complete center-back” by scout guru Jacek Kulig—blazing speed, raw power, ball-playing silk. Debut at 17 for Monaco? 135 caps by the time Chelsea called? This screamed “steal of the century.” Pundits drooled; fans etched his name on the starting XI in Sharpie. But fast-forward: Too many brain-freeze gaffes, and he’s lucky to sniff 16 starts last season. He’s no total trainwreck like Koulibaly, but that spark? Fizzled. Still, with fitness back on track, maybe there’s a redemption arc brewing. Spoiler: His partner’s story ain’t so rosy.

koulibaly-chelsea
koulibaly-chelsea

Enter Axel Disasi, the French international once hailed as Chelsea’s next John Terry—and the guy Jamie Carragher now says they have to dump like yesterday’s gym socks. This 27-year-old bruiser from Gonesse washed up at Stamford Bridge in summer 2023 amid sky-high hype. World Cup final cameo the prior winter? Ligue 1 destroyer? Scout Kulig had crowned him a “true hidden gem” years back, a Virgil van Dijk clone “born to play in England.” Fans were all in—picture the electric buzz when he nodded home a debut equalizer against Liverpool. Boom: Instant hero status.

The fairy tale peaked in February’s Etihad showdown with Man City. Disasi was a colossus, stonewalling the champs like it was personal. Post-match, Carragher—Liverpool legend and no softie—gushed it was a straight-up “John Terry performance,” the kind that drags a draw out of thin air against the unbeatable machine. Terry? That’s Chelsea royalty, the ultimate blue-blooded benchmark. Disasi had arrived.

 
 
Disasi’s Chelsea Stats The Raw Numbers
Appearances 61
Minutes 4,974
Starts 56
Goals 5
Assists 2
Points per Game 1.89
 

All stats via Transfermarkt

Flash forward, and it’s a horror show. The Prem’s meat grinder exposed him—rusty reads, shaky duels, form dipping faster than a bad stock tip. Pochettino propped him up anyway, but the shine wore off quick. Last season? Half at Chelsea, half loaned to Aston Villa, where he mustered just 10 cameos without leaving a dent. Now? Enzo Maresca’s frozen him out of the “bomb squad,” leaving Disasi twisting in the wind while pocketing £80k a week. That’s prime rib money for benchwarming.

Carragher’s verdict cuts deep: This ain’t sustainable. For Disasi’s sanity and Chelsea’s books, it’s time to cut bait. Sell high(ish), regroup, and move on. The Boehly era’s been a boom-or-bust saga, but clinging to flops like this? That’s how you sink the ship. What’s the play, Blues? January fire sale, anyone?