The Buffalo Bills are facing a pivotal moment in their backfield as 2026 looms, with star running back James Cook’s contract extension talks stalled. Without a new deal, Cook could be on his way out, leaving a significant void in Buffalo’s high-powered offense. However, the Bills are not sitting idly by. With a bold strategy in place, they’re eyeing a blockbuster move to secure one of the most electrifying running back prospects in recent memory: Oregon’s Makhi Hughes. This potential swap could shake up the NFL and signal Buffalo’s intent to dominate the ground game for years to come.
The James Cook Conundrum
James Cook has been a dynamic force for the Bills since being drafted in 2022, showcasing his speed, vision, and versatility as both a rusher and a pass-catcher. However, with his contract nearing its end and negotiations at a standstill, the Bills are preparing for life after Cook. While the team has Ray Davis, a promising back under contract through 2027, relying solely on him may not be enough to sustain Buffalo’s Super Bowl aspirations. The Bills need a game-changer, and they may have found one in Makhi Hughes.
Enter Makhi Hughes: The 3,000-Yard Phenom
Makhi Hughes, who transferred to Oregon in 2025 after a stellar two-year stint at Tulane, is a name every NFL scout is buzzing about. Over his time with the Green Wave, Hughes racked up an impressive 3,000+ yards from scrimmage, including 2,779 yards on the ground—tops among FBS running backs returning to college in 2025. In 2024 alone, he powered his way to 1,401 rushing yards and 15 touchdowns, proving he can handle a heavy workload with 523 carries over two seasons.
What makes Hughes a perfect fit for Buffalo? His blend of size (5-foot-11, 210 pounds), power, and explosiveness makes him a three-down back capable of breaking games open. Additionally, Hughes has shown growth as a pass-catcher, posting career highs in 2024 with 19 receptions, 176 receiving yards, and two touchdown catches. This versatility aligns perfectly with the Bills’ offensive scheme, which thrives on dynamic playmakers who can contribute in multiple facets.
Why Hughes Could Be the Answer
At Oregon, Hughes is stepping into a bigger spotlight, facing tougher competition in the Pac-12. If he maintains or exceeds his Tulane production while further refining his receiving skills, he could cement himself as a top running back prospect in the 2026 NFL Draft. Pro Football & Sports Network’s Mark Stolte projects the Bills to target Hughes in the second round, a move that would signal their commitment to rebuilding their backfield with elite talent.
Hughes’ ability to handle a high carry count, combined with his explosive playmaking, makes him an ideal candidate to replace Cook. His physical running style complements Josh Allen’s dual-threat presence, creating a balanced attack that could keep defenses on their heels. Moreover, Hughes’ improving pass-catching ability ensures he can stay on the field in passing situations, a critical trait in Buffalo’s pass-heavy offense.
A Blockbuster Vision for Buffalo’s Future
Drafting Hughes would be more than just a replacement for Cook—it would be a statement. The Bills are signaling to the NFL that they’re not content to merely maintain their roster; they’re aiming to elevate it. Pairing Hughes with Ray Davis could create a formidable one-two punch in the backfield, giving Buffalo the depth and versatility needed to compete with the AFC’s elite.
As Hughes prepares to showcase his talents at Oregon, all eyes will be on his ability to dominate against top-tier competition. If he delivers, the Bills could land a true difference-maker in 2026, putting the entire NFL on notice. Buffalo’s bold plan to swap Cook for an elite 3,000-yard rusher like Hughes could be the key to unlocking their Super Bowl potential.