/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/24687621/1455488162.jpg)
The Kansas City Chiefs have been proactive in reshaping their offensive line during the offseason, addressing the significant loss of All-Pro guard Joe Thuney with the additions of tackles Jaylon Moore and Josh Simmons. These moves signal a clear intent to bolster the line’s depth and flexibility, particularly at tackle, where Moore and Simmons are expected to compete for the starting left tackle role. The competition could even spill over to the right side, where Jawaan Taylor’s lingering knee injury from last season raises questions about his readiness.
However, the bigger uncertainty for the Chiefs may not lie with their new arrivals but with a returning player: Kingsley Suamataia, their 2024 second-round draft pick. Suamataia’s rookie season at left tackle didn’t secure him a starting role, prompting the team to transition him to guard in hopes of unlocking his potential. With Thuney’s departure leaving a vacancy at left guard, Suamataia has a golden opportunity to claim the spot. But if he fails to impress during training camp, the Chiefs’ depth behind him is thin, with only Mike Caliendo—a 2024 starter with a lackluster 49.0 Pro Football Focus (PFF) grade—as a viable alternative.
A Trade Proposal to Address the Gap
Enter Liam Eichenberg, a guard from the Miami Dolphins, who could serve as a safety net for the Chiefs. Reports suggest Kansas City is exploring a trade to acquire Eichenberg, and the reasoning is straightforward: insurance. Eichenberg, a four-year veteran with 46 career starts, brings experience and affordability on a one-year, $2.25 million contract. While his performance has been inconsistent—evidenced by a 53.1 PFF grade in 2024, only marginally better than Caliendo’s—he has shown better results playing inside at guard compared to his stints at tackle.
Eichenberg isn’t a game-changer or a long-term solution for Kansas City’s offensive line. However, he represents a low-risk, high-upside addition who could step in if Suamataia struggles or if injuries further deplete the line. His role would be to provide stability and reliability, not to revolutionize the Chiefs’ offense.
Why Trade Suamataia?
The idea of trading Suamataia, a recent second-round pick, might raise eyebrows, but it aligns with the Chiefs’ pragmatic approach. Suamataia’s potential is undeniable, but his inability to lock down the left tackle role in 2024 and the uncertainty surrounding his transition to guard suggest he may not be ready to anchor the line. If his performance in camp underwhelms, the Chiefs could view him as a valuable trade chip to acquire a proven veteran like Eichenberg, who offers immediate depth and flexibility.
Moreover, the Chiefs’ offensive line is under pressure to protect their quarterback and sustain their high-powered offense. With Moore and Simmons vying for tackle spots and Taylor’s health in question, Kansas City can’t afford to gamble on Suamataia’s development without a fallback plan.
What’s in It for Miami?
For the Dolphins, Eichenberg appears expendable. Miami’s recent acquisitions of free agents James Daniels and Daniel Brunskill, along with second-round pick Jonah Savaiinaea, have pushed Eichenberg down the depth chart. With the Dolphins not in a “win-now” mode, trading Eichenberg for a young, high-upside player like Suamataia could be appealing. Suamataia’s athleticism and draft pedigree make him an intriguing developmental prospect for Miami, who could afford to be patient with his growth.
The Proposed Deal
The trade under consideration could look like this:
Kansas City Chiefs receive: Liam Eichenberg
Miami Dolphins receive: Kingsley Suamataia
This deal would be a low-stakes, high-reward move for both teams. For the Chiefs, Eichenberg provides a safety net, ensuring their offensive line remains functional even if Suamataia doesn’t pan out. For the Dolphins, Suamataia offers a chance to invest in a player with significant potential, aligning with their longer-term roster-building strategy.
Why It Makes Sense
This trade isn’t about flashy headlines or blockbuster names—it’s about practical roster management. The Chiefs are in a championship window and need reliability on their offensive line to protect their quarterback and maintain offensive efficiency. Eichenberg’s experience and affordability make him an ideal stopgap, while Suamataia’s youth and potential could benefit a Dolphins team looking to build for the future.
While the trade isn’t finalized, the logic behind it is clear: Kansas City is prioritizing stability, and Miami is open to taking a chance on upside. If Suamataia’s camp performance doesn’t inspire confidence, expect the Chiefs to move quickly to secure a veteran like Eichenberg. This isn’t just a rumor—it’s a strategic move that could shape the Chiefs’ offensive line for the 2025 season.