The New York Yankees are navigating a critical phase of their 2025 season, with their dynamic second baseman Jazz Chisholm Jr. sidelined by a severe right oblique strain. Acquired from the Miami Marlins at the 2024 trade deadline, Chisholm has been a sparkplug for the team, bringing elite defense, blazing speed, and a vibrant personality to the Bronx. However, a high-grade oblique injury sustained on April 29, 2025, during a game against the Baltimore Orioles has kept him out of action, prompting the Yankees to devise a bold and carefully calculated rehab plan to ensure his return strengthens their postseason push. Here’s the untold story behind Chisholm’s recovery journey and the Yankees’ strategic approach to getting their star infielder back on the field.
The Injury: A Setback for a Rising Star
Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s injury occurred in the first inning of a 15-3 rout of the Orioles, when he grimaced after fouling off a pitch and later doubled down the right-field line. Initially described as “right flank discomfort,” the injury was later clarified as a high-grade right oblique strain, with an MRI revealing three separate microtears in the muscle. According to Dr. Elise C. Bixby, an orthopedic surgeon at NYU Langone Hospital, this complex injury—unusual for its multiple tear sites—requires a delicate recovery process to prevent further damage. While Chisholm remained optimistic, telling reporters he felt “fine” and downplaying the severity, the Yankees’ medical staff took a cautious approach, placing him on the 10-day injured list on May 2, retroactive to April 30. Manager Aaron Boone estimated a recovery timeline of four to six weeks, a prognosis that could have derailed the team’s momentum in the tightly contested AL East race.
Chisholm’s absence is significant. Despite a .181 batting average this season, his 102 OPS+, seven home runs, 17 RBIs, and six stolen bases in just 30 games underscore his value. His Gold Glove-caliber defense at second base, with three Defensive Runs Saved and three Outs Above Average, and his 99th-percentile baserunning have made him a cornerstone of the Yankees’ lineup. Without him, the team’s second-base production has been among the league’s worst, with backups like Oswald Peraza and Jorbit Vivas struggling to fill the void.
The Yankees’ Bold Rehab Strategy
The Yankees’ front office, often criticized for a lack of contingency planning, has responded to Chisholm’s injury with a meticulous rehab plan designed to balance speed and caution. On May 26, 2025, Chisholm posted a video on his Instagram story, swinging in a batting cage with the caption, “We gon have a problem,” signaling his confidence in a swift return. The following day, Aaron Boone provided an encouraging update: Chisholm is scheduled for a full workout on May 28, which includes hitting against high-velocity pitching, fielding grounders, and testing his mobility. If all goes well, he could begin a minor-league rehab assignment later in the week, potentially with Double-A Somerset or Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre.
This rehab plan is a departure from Chisholm’s own instincts. Known for his fiery competitiveness, Chisholm expressed frustration with rehab stints at a recent charity event, preferring to jump straight back into major-league action. However, the Yankees are prioritizing long-term health over a premature return, especially given the risk of re-injury with oblique strains. Boone emphasized that Chisholm must demonstrate he can swing and field without discomfort, likely requiring one or two minor-league games to regain his timing. This cautious approach is informed by the team’s broader injury challenges, with key players like Giancarlo Stanton, Gerrit Cole, and Oswaldo Cabrera also on the mend.
The Strategic Implications
The Yankees’ decision to implement a structured rehab plan reflects their high stakes in the 2025 season. With a 30-19 record and a five-game lead in the AL East as of May 26, the team is well-positioned for a postseason run, but Chisholm’s return could be a game-changer. His versatility—having played center field, second base, and third base—and his pull-side power, which aligns perfectly with Yankee Stadium’s short right-field porch, make him a critical asset. Moreover, his chemistry with shortstop Anthony Volpe, both on and off the field, promises to bolster the Yankees’ infield defense, projected to be among the league’s best.
The rehab plan also navigates a potential logjam at second base. Veteran DJ LeMahieu, who is nearing a return from a left calf strain and right hip discomfort, has looked rejuvenated in his minor-league rehab assignment. However, with Chisholm entrenched as the primary second baseman, LeMahieu is likely to shift to third base upon his return, potentially displacing Peraza and Vivas. This flexibility allows the Yankees to maintain depth while maximizing Chisholm’s impact.
The Untold Story: Chisholm’s Drive and the Yankees’ Culture Shift
Beyond the physical rehab, the untold story lies in Chisholm’s relentless drive and the Yankees’ evolving culture. Known for his flamboyant style—custom cleats, anime-inspired jewelry, and a larger-than-life personality—Chisholm initially faced resistance in Miami, where veterans criticized his individuality. In contrast, Aaron Boone has embraced Chisholm’s authenticity, fostering an environment where he can thrive. This cultural shift, evident in Boone’s encouragement during their first phone call post-trade, has allowed Chisholm to flourish, as seen in his .273/.325/.500 slash line over 46 regular-season games with the Yankees in 2024.
Chisholm’s rehab journey is also a testament to his resilience. Having overcome injuries like a 2022 stress fracture and a 2024 UCL sprain, he views this oblique strain as another “battle scar.” His optimism, coupled with the Yankees’ strategic rehab plan, sets the stage for a dramatic return that could reshape the team’s postseason fortunes.
Looking Ahead
As Chisholm progresses through his rehab assignment, the Yankees are poised to reintegrate a player who could redefine their lineup. With Stanton and pitcher Luis Gil also nearing returns, the team’s depth is improving at a critical juncture. While Chisholm’s batting average has been inconsistent, his career-low 21.1% chase rate and improved plate discipline suggest a potential breakout upon his return. The Yankees’ bold rehab plan, balancing caution with urgency, underscores their commitment to leveraging Chisholm’s unique talents in their quest for a World Series title.
For now, fans await the moment when Chisholm, with his purple sunglasses and infectious energy, steps back onto the field at Yankee Stadium, ready to dance with Boone and ignite the Bronx once more.