The Buffalo Bills could look to the 2026 NFL draft if they need to replace James Cook.
The Buffalo Bills are facing a pivotal moment in their backfield as running back James Cook’s contract negotiations remain unresolved. With Cook’s return in 2026 uncertain, the Bills are proactively eyeing the 2026 NFL Draft to secure a dynamic replacement. Enter Roman Hemby, a versatile and explosive running back from Indiana, who could be the key to keeping Buffalo’s offense firing on all cylinders.
The James Cook Conundrum
James Cook has been a cornerstone of the Bills’ offense, showcasing his dual-threat ability as a rusher and receiver. However, with his contract set to expire after the 2025 season and no new deal in sight, the Bills are preparing for a future without their star running back. While rookie Ray Davis, a powerful runner with a bruising style, could step into a larger role, Buffalo is likely to bolster their backfield through the draft to maintain their offensive versatility.
Roman Hemby: The Perfect Fit
Pro Football and Sports Network’s Joe DeLeone recently mocked Indiana running back Roman Hemby to the Bills in the third round of his 2026 NFL mock draft. Hemby, who transferred to Indiana from Maryland for his fifth collegiate season, is poised to make a significant impact in 2025 and could seamlessly fill the void left by Cook.
Hemby’s collegiate career at Maryland was nothing short of impressive. Over four years, he amassed 2,347 rushing yards, 921 receiving yards, and 27 total touchdowns. In 2024 alone, he recorded 607 rushing yards, 273 receiving yards, and seven scores, despite splitting carries. His career average of 4.8 yards per carry in his final two seasons at Maryland, combined with 112 receptions, highlights his ability to contribute as both a rusher and a pass-catcher—qualities that mirror Cook’s skill set.
Hemby’s explosive speed and keen vision make him a nightmare for defenders in open space, while his receiving prowess adds a dimension that keeps defenses guessing. Paired with Ray Davis’ physical, downhill running style, Hemby could form a dynamic duo in Buffalo’s backfield, ensuring the Bills lose no firepower if Cook departs.
A Fresh Start at Indiana
Hemby’s transfer to Indiana for the 2025 season offers a golden opportunity to showcase his talents. With Indiana’s top two rushers from 2024 having graduated, Hemby is primed to take on a featured role in the Hoosiers’ offense. If he can replicate or surpass his 2022 breakout campaign at Maryland—where he burst onto the scene as a versatile playmaker—his draft stock could soar, making him an even more enticing pick for the Bills.
Why Rivals Should Be Terrified
The thought of Hemby joining forces with Josh Allen and the Bills’ high-octane offense is enough to send shivers down the spines of AFC rivals. His ability to break off big runs, combined with his soft hands and elusiveness in the passing game, makes him a perfect fit for Buffalo’s scheme. Add in Davis’ punishing runs, and the Bills could have a backfield tandem capable of dominating in multiple ways.
Hemby’s 27 career touchdowns are a testament to his playmaking ability, earning him the moniker of a “destroyer” on the field. His arrival in Buffalo could signal a seamless transition from Cook, ensuring the Bills remain a formidable force in the NFL.
Looking Ahead
While the Bills hope to resolve their contract standoff with James Cook, their forward-thinking approach to the 2026 NFL Draft demonstrates their commitment to staying ahead of the curve. Roman Hemby’s blend of speed, vision, and pass-catching ability makes him an ideal candidate to carry the torch in Buffalo’s backfield. If Hemby lands with the Bills, NFL defenses will need to brace for impact, as this “destroyer” could take the league by storm.
