Reflecting on the Boston Red Sox’s tumultuous 2025 season, one decision stands out as a glaring misstep: the one-year, $21.05 million pact with Walker Buehler. What was meant to bolster the rotation turned into a full-blown fiasco, leaving fans reeling and the front office second-guessing every move.
To put it bluntly, Buehler’s stint in a Red Sox jersey was nothing short of disastrous. He limped to a 7-7 record with a bloated 5.45 ERA over 22 starts and a lone relief appearance, failing to deliver the ace-level stuff that had defined his Dodgers days. The sting deepened when Buehler, after a midseason trade, rediscovered his form with the Philadelphia Phillies. In a late-season surge, he tossed 13.2 stellar innings, earning a coveted spot on their NLDS roster and reminding everyone of the pitcher who once dominated October.
The ill-fated Buehler-Boston union ended in a swift parting, but fresh revelations have poured salt on the wound for Red Sox faithful. According to The New York Post’s Jon Heyman, Buehler could have stayed put in Los Angeles—where he belonged. The Dodgers, fresh off their 2024 World Series triumph, extended a one-year, $20 million offer last offseason. Buehler turned it down flat.
This bombshell shatters lingering rumors that LA had matched Boston’s $21.05 million bid, fueling endless speculation about why Buehler bolted from a championship contender. Was it frustration with the Dodgers’ coaching? A desire for a bigger payday? Or deeper tensions brewing behind the scenes? Fans were left scratching their heads, wondering how fiscal near-equality could lead to such a drastic exit.
Embed X: https://twitter.com/MLBONFOX/status/1959000105249320969
In the end, Buehler chased the extra cash—and who could fault him? Baseball is a business, after all. Yet, whispers persist that other factors played a role, perhaps unresolved issues from his LA tenure that made a fresh start in Boston seem appealing. Whatever the truth, it doesn’t soften the blow for Red Sox fans, who now wish Buehler had never left Dodger blue.
Beyond his on-field struggles, Buehler’s presence clogged Boston’s pipeline, delaying the ascent of promising arms like Connelly Early and Payton Tolle. An earlier integration could have fortified the rotation and positioned the Sox for a deeper postseason run. Instead, it was another brick in the wall of a frustrating campaign.
But hey, the page turns. As the Dodgers edge two wins from their second straight World Series—sans Buehler—Red Sox Nation clings to offseason optimism. With phenom Roman Anthony and the core crew in tow, there’s hope brewing that come 2026, Boston will be the ones battling under the bright lights of October.