Skip to main content

Breaking: Buffalo Bills Quietly Plotting to ‘Steal’ Tyreek Hill from Dolphins, Shaking Up the AFC East!

Posted on June 2, 2025 - 2:55 am by

As the Buffalo Bills head into another season with championship expectations, questions remain about their wide receiver corps.

Despite having a reliable option in Khalil Shakir, the supporting cast-led by rookie Keon Coleman, and veterans Joshua Palmer and Elijah Moore-lacks top-tier experience and production. With superstar quarterback Josh Allen in his prime, Buffalo’s offense is in need of another game-breaking weapon.

This has sparked speculation in league circles and media chatter about bold moves that could elevate the Bills’ offense. One such scenario? Trading for Miami Dolphins star wide receiver Tyreek Hill.

Tyreek Hill – The Perfect Piece for the Bills?

The idea of pursuing Tyreek Hill was floated by Pro Football Talk’s Mike Florio, who suggested that the Bills are among several teams that should “at least consider” going after the superstar, alongside the Ravens, Texans, Chargers, and 49ers. With his explosive speed and playmaking ability, Hill would give Josh Allen an elite deep threat and a proven target. Pairing Hill with Coleman or Shakir could instantly resolve Buffalo’s wide receiver depth issues, transforming their offense into an unstoppable force.

However, this dream comes with significant hurdles.

Tyreek Hill could solve Buffalo’s WR concerns – But at what cost?

Pro Football Talk’s Mike Florio floated the idea, suggesting the Bills are among several contenders that should “at least ponder” pursuing Hill. He included the Ravens, Texans, Chargers, and 49ers in that conversation, but also acknowledged the obvious hurdle: Miami helping a division rival is extremely unlikely.

In theory, adding Hill makes perfect sense. He remains one of the NFL’s most electrifying playmakers and would give Allen an elite deep threat and proven target-an upgrade that could reshape Buffalo’s passing attack overnight. Placing Hill opposite Coleman or Shakir could instantly solve the Bills’ WR depth concerns.

But while the fit looks perfect on paper, the reality is far more complicated.

First, the financial picture is grim. Hill carries $27.6 million in guaranteed money in 2025 alone. Meanwhile, the Bills have just $1.6 million in available cap space-far too little to absorb a deal of that size, even with creative maneuvering from GM Brandon Beane.

Second, and perhaps more importantly, there’s no indication that the Dolphins are even open to moving Hill. Miami GM Chris Grier has been clear: it would take two first-round picks just to start the conversation.

And considering Hill is under contract and still producing at a high level, the Dolphins have little incentive to part ways with him-especially to a direct AFC East rival.

Hill himself has sent mixed messages about his long-term future in Miami, but nothing concrete suggests a trade is imminent. Until that changes, Buffalo‘s hopes of landing Hill remain speculative at best.

Ultimately, as exciting as a Tyreek Hill acquisition would be for the Bills, it’s not a realistic scenario. The idea underscores the team’s need for an elite receiving option, but the path forward likely lies elsewhere-whether through internal development, a smaller trade, or a late free agent signing.

Hill might be the kind of player who could put Buffalo over the top. Unfortunately, every road to making that dream a reality is blocked-for now.

Massive Obstacles

Financial Constraints

Financially, the deal seems nearly impossible. Tyreek Hill carries a contract with $27.6 million in guaranteed money for 2025 alone. Meanwhile, the Buffalo Bills have just $1.6 million in available cap space—a figure far too small to absorb such a massive contract, even with the most creative financial maneuvering from GM Brandon Beane.

Miami Dolphins’ Reluctance

More critically, there’s no indication that the Miami Dolphins are open to trading Hill, especially to a direct AFC East rival. According to Miami GM Chris Grier, any conversation about moving Hill would start with a price tag of at least two first-round draft picks. With Hill still performing at an elite level and under contract, the Dolphins have little incentive to let him go—particularly to a competitor like the Bills.

Tyreek Hill’s Intentions

Hill himself has sent mixed signals about his long-term future in Miami, but nothing concrete suggests he’s pushing for a trade. This leaves any speculation about a potential move purely hypothetical for now.

Can the Bills Find a Way?

While the idea of bringing Tyreek Hill to Buffalo sounds like a perfect dream, the reality is far more complicated. The financial barriers, Miami’s firm stance, and Hill’s contract situation all present formidable roadblocks. However, this rumor underscores the Bills’ ambition to find a true star receiver to complement Josh Allen.

Instead of banking on a near-impossible trade, the Bills may need to explore other options. Developing internal talents like Keon Coleman, pursuing a smaller trade, or signing a late free agent could be more realistic paths forward.

Conclusion

Tyreek Hill could be the missing piece to propel the Buffalo Bills closer to a Super Bowl, but the path to acquiring him is fraught with obstacles. While the rumor of a blockbuster trade may excite fans, the Bills will likely need to focus on more practical solutions to bolster their offense. Regardless, the mere idea of Tyreek Hill in a Bills uniform is enough to send shockwaves through the AFC East!