The Dallas Cowboys are at a crossroads as they head into the 2025 season, and the team’s official website has sparked a fiery debate with their “20 Questions” series. This week’s question is a big one: which former first-round pick needs to make a bigger leap in 2025—Mazi Smith or Tyler Guyton? The staff is split, with compelling arguments on both sides, highlighting the critical roles these young players could play in turning the Cowboys into contenders. Let’s break down why this question matters and what it means for America’s Team.
The Case for Mazi Smith
Mazi Smith, the Cowboys’ 2023 first-round pick, was drafted to be a dominant force at the 1-tech defensive tackle position. Tommy Yarrish and Kurt Daniels both argue that Smith’s development is crucial for Dallas’ defense. Yarrish believes Smith could “change the entire trajectory of the Cowboys’ defense” if he becomes the run-stuffer they envisioned. A strong 1-tech is the backbone of a stout defense, clogging lanes and freeing up linebackers to make plays. Daniels echoed this, noting that while the offensive line needs help, the Cowboys have more flexibility at tackle than at defensive tackle. Without a dominant 1-tech, opponents can exploit Dallas’ run defense, which struggled at times last season. Smith’s size (6’3”, 337 lbs) and athleticism make him a high-upside player, but his limited impact so far—only 3.5 sacks over two seasons—means 2025 is a make-or-break year.
The Case for Tyler Guyton
On the other side, Kyle Youmans and Patrik Walker argue that Tyler Guyton, the 2024 first-round pick, is the player who needs to step up most. As the left tackle protecting Dak Prescott’s blindside, Guyton’s role is critical. Prescott, an All-Pro quarterback and former NFL MVP runner-up, is coming off a devastating hamstring injury in 2024, which occurred while escaping pocket pressure. Youmans emphasized that Guyton’s performance directly impacts Prescott’s health and the offense’s success. Walker, while acknowledging Smith’s importance, stressed that “protecting the blindside of an All-Pro quarterback” is paramount. Guyton showed flashes of potential last season but struggled with consistency, allowing 6 sacks in 12 starts. With the Cowboys’ offense relying heavily on Prescott’s playmaking, Guyton’s ability to lock down the left tackle spot could determine whether Dallas can compete with elite NFC teams like the Philadelphia Eagles or Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
The Bigger Picture
The Cowboys have built a reputation for nailing first-round picks, with stars like Micah Parsons and CeeDee Lamb anchoring the roster. However, Smith and Guyton have yet to live up to their draft pedigree. Smith’s development has been slowed by injuries and a crowded defensive line rotation, while Guyton faced a steep learning curve transitioning to the NFL’s premier left tackle role. If either player breaks out in 2025, it could elevate Dallas to new heights. If both do, the Cowboys could have a special season, with a dominant defense and a protected quarterback fueling a deep playoff run. The team’s recent draft success gives fans hope, but the clock is ticking for these young players to prove themselves.
Challenges and Opportunities
The debate highlights the Cowboys’ high stakes in 2025. Smith faces pressure to become the anchor of a defensive front that needs to stop the run against physical teams like the San Francisco 49ers. His ability to command double-teams could unleash Parsons and DeMarvion Overshown, making Dallas’ defense elite. Meanwhile, Guyton must improve his technique and strength to handle speed rushers like Haason Reddick or Aidan Hutchinson. The Cowboys’ coaching staff, led by Mike McCarthy, will need to maximize these players’ potential through targeted development. Off the field, Dallas is also navigating free agency, with reports naming them an ideal landing spot for a surprising pending free agent. A strengthened roster could complement a breakout from Smith or Guyton, but the team’s success hinges on these young stars stepping up.
The Mazi Smith vs. Tyler Guyton debate underscores the Cowboys’ quest to balance a dominant defense with a protected offense. Whether it’s Smith clogging the middle or Guyton shielding Dak Prescott, both players are pivotal to Dallas’ 2025 aspirations. Fans, who do you think needs to make the bigger leap? Drop your thoughts in the comments and let’s get the conversation going! Will the Cowboys finally break through in the playoffs, or are Smith and Guyton still a year away?