The Dallas Cowboys are gearing up for their mandatory minicamp from June 10 to June 12, 2025, and all eyes are on a new face in the quarterback room: Joe Milton III. Acquired in a trade with the New England Patriots in April 2025, Milton has been generating buzz as a potential “secret weapon” for the Cowboys, with CBS Sports’ Cody Benjamin predicting he could make significant noise during minicamp. With his freakish athleticism, powerful arm, and early impressions at OTAs, Milton is positioning himself as a contender for the backup quarterback role behind Dak Prescott. But have opponents taken notice of this rising star yet?
A Promising Start in Dallas
Joe Milton, a 2024 sixth-round pick by the Patriots, arrived in Dallas with limited NFL experience but an abundance of raw talent. His lone start in Week 18 of the 2024 season against the Buffalo Bills showcased his potential, as he completed 22 of 29 passes for 241 yards, threw a touchdown, and added a rushing touchdown—capped with a viral backflip in the end zone. This performance, albeit against Buffalo’s backups, caught the attention of the Cowboys’ front office, leading to a low-risk trade that sent a 2025 fifth-round pick to New England for Milton and a seventh-round pick.
Since joining the Cowboys, Milton has impressed during Organized Team Activities (OTAs). Reports from Dallas indicate he’s made eye-popping throws, including a red zone touchdown to newly acquired wide receiver George Pickens and a precise seam route to tight end Princeton Fant. Head coach Brian Schottenheimer has been vocal about his excitement, stating, “The talent speaks for itself. He’s made some incredible throws. He’s just an exciting young prospect that I think the sky’s the limit for.” Milton’s integration into the quarterback room alongside Dak Prescott and Will Grier has been seamless, with the young quarterback expressing gratitude for the mentorship he’s receiving.
The ‘Secret Weapon’ Factor
Milton’s athleticism and physical traits set him apart. Standing at 6’6” with a cannon arm capable of a 61.7mph pass (the second-fastest ever recorded in the NFL), he’s been compared to Josh Allen for his big arm and sturdy frame. His viral backflip during a Cowboys OTA practice, performed in full gear, further highlighted his freakish athleticism, drawing attention from fans and media alike. CBS Sports’ Cody Benjamin noted Milton’s potential to be a “sleeper weapon,” suggesting that his performances in minicamp could elevate his profile significantly.
Milton’s unique study habits also add to his intrigue. He’s been working with his girlfriend to master the Cowboys’ playbook, using a creative method of setting up plays with chips on a makeshift line of scrimmage. This dedication, combined with his raw talent, has Schottenheimer and the coaching staff optimistic about his development. As Milton himself said, “The only thing I did at that moment was thank God. Coming here was a blessing.”
Have Opponents Taken Notice?
While Milton’s performances in OTAs have generated excitement within the Cowboys’ organization and fanbase, it’s less clear whether opposing teams have taken notice. His limited NFL tape—primarily from one start against a Bills team resting starters—means he remains an unknown quantity to many. The Cowboys’ offense, described by Milton as “fast and explosive” compared to the Patriots’ more rigid system, could amplify his impact, but opponents are likely focusing on Dallas’ established stars like Dak Prescott, CeeDee Lamb, and the newly acquired George Pickens.
However, Milton’s potential to disrupt defenses shouldn’t be underestimated. His ability to make downfield throws and his mobility could pose problems for teams preparing to face Dallas’ high-powered offense. If he secures the backup role over Will Grier, as some reports suggest he’s trending toward, opponents may start game-planning for the possibility of Milton stepping in, especially given Prescott’s injury history in 2024. For now, Milton remains a wildcard—a low-cost, high-reward investment that could catch teams off guard if he sees the field.
Challenges and Competition Ahead
Despite the hype, Milton faces challenges. His rawness as a prospect, with only one NFL start and a six-year college career at Michigan and Tennessee, means he’s still developing the mental processing required for the quarterback position. He’s competing with Will Grier for the backup role, and while Milton has taken second-team reps at OTAs, Grier’s experience with the Cowboys’ system gives him an edge. Additionally, Milton’s time with the Patriots was marked by a less dynamic offense, and adapting to Dallas’ more complex playbook will be critical.
The Cowboys’ history with developmental quarterbacks, such as the failed Trey Lance experiment, adds pressure for Milton to prove himself. However, the low cost of his acquisition and his $1 million annual salary make him a low-risk gamble with significant upside. Minicamp will be a crucial opportunity for Milton to showcase his progress and solidify his role as Prescott’s primary backup.
Conclusion
Joe Milton III is poised to make waves at the Dallas Cowboys’ 2025 minicamp, living up to his billing as a “secret weapon.” His athleticism, arm talent, and early OTA performances have already turned heads, and his development under Brian Schottenheimer and alongside Dak Prescott could unlock his immense potential. While opponents may not yet be zeroing in on Milton, his performances in minicamp could force them to take notice. As the Cowboys aim for dominance in the 2025 season, Milton’s journey from a sixth-round pick to a potential game-changer is one to watch closely.