The Philadelphia Eagles are at a crossroads with one of their most reliable offensive weapons, tight end Dallas Goedert. Known for his clutch performances and chemistry with quarterback Jalen Hurts, Goedert has been a cornerstone of the Eagles’ high-powered offense. However, Bleacher Report’s Kristopher Knox recently stirred the pot by suggesting that the Eagles should consider placing the 30-year-old star on the trade block during the NFL preseason. While this bold claim might raise eyebrows among Philly fans, there’s a case to be made—and it’s not just about cap space.
Dallas Goedert has proven his worth time and again, especially during Philadelphia’s run to Super Bowl LIV. Despite missing chunks of the regular season due to injuries, he delivered in the playoffs, racking up 215 yards and a touchdown. Last season, Goedert showcased his reliability, hauling in 80.8% of his targets—a career-high—and averaging 11.8 yards per catch, the third-highest mark of his eight-year career. His soft hands and knack for getting open make him one of the NFL’s premier tight ends, a player Jalen Hurts leans on when the game is on the line.
Goedert’s route-running finesse and ability to make contested catches have cemented his role as a safety valve for Hurts. In an offense stacked with playmakers like A.J. Brown, DeVonta Smith, and Saquon Barkley, Goedert’s consistent production adds a dimension that few tight ends can match. His presence stretches defenses, creating opportunities for the Eagles’ explosive passing game.
So, why would the Eagles even entertain trading such a dynamic player? According to Knox, it’s all about timing and depth. The Eagles bolstered their tight end room this offseason by adding Kylen Granson and Harrison Bryant, while second-year player Grant Calcaterra showed promise last season with 298 yards and a touchdown. Calcaterra’s emergence, in particular, has sparked conversations about the future of the position in Philadelphia.
Knox points out that the Eagles explored trading Goedert earlier this offseason, even receiving offers during the draft before restructuring his contract, per Jeff McLane of The Philadelphia Inquirer. The restructure makes it easier for Philly to carry multiple tight ends in 2025, but it only saves $1.3 million in cap space if Goedert is traded. The real incentive? Goedert, an impending 2026 free agent, could fetch valuable draft capital—something Eagles GM Howie Roseman has a knack for capitalizing on.
Roseman’s reputation as a master of trading players at their peak value is well-documented. With Goedert turning 30 and having missed 15 games over the past three seasons due to injuries, the Eagles might see this as the perfect window to maximize his trade value before durability concerns lower his stock. While Goedert remains a key piece of the offensive puzzle, the depth at tight end gives Philadelphia options to pivot without losing too much firepower.
On the flip side, moving Goedert could be a risky gamble for a team with Super Bowl aspirations. The Eagles’ offense is loaded in 2025, and Goedert’s unique skill set is a big reason why. Unlike Calcaterra, who has yet to prove he can replicate Goedert’s big-play ability, the veteran tight end is a proven “home run hitter” at the position. His ability to turn short passes into significant gains and his reliability in critical moments make him indispensable to Hurts and offensive coordinator Kellen Moore.
Losing Goedert could disrupt the chemistry of an offense that’s poised to dominate. While Calcaterra, Granson, and Bryant provide depth, none have shown they can fully replace Goedert’s production or his role as a security blanket for Hurts. Trading him now, especially with a contending roster, might jeopardize Philly’s chances of hoisting the Lombardi Trophy.
The idea of trading Dallas Goedert is a classic case of short-term pain for long-term gain. Howie Roseman’s track record suggests he’s unafraid to make bold moves, and the Eagles’ depth at tight end gives them flexibility to explore offers. If Roseman can secure high-value draft picks for Goedert, it could set Philadelphia up for sustained success beyond 2025. However, parting ways with one of Jalen Hurts’ favorite targets could throw a wrench in the Eagles’ Super Bowl plans.