In a stunning turn of events, a former Arsenal academy star, once sold for a mere £540,000, has been likened to football legend Lionel Messi following an electrifying performance in the Premier League. Donyell Malen, who parted ways with Arsenal in 2017, has re-emerged as a force to be reckoned with, catching the attention of fans and pundits alike with his recent heroics for Aston Villa.

A Bargain Departure from Arsenal
Arsenal’s decision to let Malen go to PSV Eindhoven for less than £1 million raised eyebrows at the time, as the young Dutch forward was seen as a promising talent within the club’s Hale End academy. With his pathway to the first team blocked, the then-teenager sought opportunities elsewhere, a move that has now proven to be a masterstroke for his career. While Arsenal’s academy has produced gems like Bukayo Saka and Emile Smith Rowe, Malen’s departure left some wondering if the Gunners had let a diamond slip through their fingers.
Malen’s journey since leaving Arsenal has been one of perseverance and growth. After finding his footing at PSV and later shining at Borussia Dortmund, the 26-year-old returned to the Premier League with Aston Villa. Initially struggling for game time under manager Unai Emery, Malen has now hit his stride, delivering a breathtaking performance that has sparked comparisons to one of the greatest players in football history.
Messi-Like Magic Against Burnley
Malen’s explosive brace against Burnley in the Premier League showcased his blistering pace, clinical finishing, and ability to glide past defenders with ease. His performance was so captivating that it became a focal point of discussion on the AD Voetbalpodcast, where hosts Etienne Verhoeff and Maarten Wijffels didn’t hold back in their praise. “He has those days… There are days when Malen gets into Messi’s shoes, and then absolutely everything works out, and then he dribbles past people,” one host remarked. Such a comparison to Lionel Messi, an eight-time Ballon d’Or winner, is no small feat and underscores the heights Malen is reaching.
The Dutch forward’s ability to take on defenders, create chances, and deliver in crucial moments has drawn parallels to Messi’s signature style. While Malen may not yet be at the Argentine’s level, his recent form suggests he has the potential to become a household name in the Premier League.
A Hale End Star Among Premier League Talents
Malen’s time at Arsenal’s academy saw him share the pitch with several players who have also carved out successful careers in the Premier League. Alongside teammates like Eddie Nketiah, Emile Smith Rowe, Joe Willock, and Dan Ballard, Malen honed his skills at Hale End, Arsenal’s renowned youth setup. While Nketiah and Smith Rowe were also moved on by Mikel Arteta in recent transfer windows, Malen’s journey highlights the unpredictable nature of academy prospects finding their way to the top.
For every success story like Saka, there are players like Malen who take a more circuitous route to stardom. His departure from Arsenal, while initially seen as a loss, has allowed him to flourish elsewhere, proving that sometimes the grass truly is greener on the other side.
A Missed Opportunity for Arsenal?
As Malen continues to shine, Arsenal fans and former manager Arsène Wenger may wonder if the club made the right call in letting him go for such a modest fee. However, the reality of academy football is that not every talented player can break into the first team. With competition for places at Arsenal being fiercer than ever, Malen’s move to PSV gave him the platform to develop into the player he is today.
His recent performances, particularly the Messi-esque display against Burnley, serve as a reminder of the fine margins in football. Arsenal’s loss has become Aston Villa’s gain, and Malen’s resurgence in the Premier League is a testament to his resilience and talent.
Looking Ahead: Malen and Timber’s International Link-Up
As Malen prepares to join the Netherlands national team for the October international break, he will link up with Arsenal’s Jurrien Timber. The pair’s connection could prove vital for the Oranje, with Malen’s attacking flair complementing Timber’s defensive solidity. Dutch fans will be hoping Malen can replicate his Messi-like form on the international stage, further cementing his status as one of Europe’s most exciting forwards.
Donyell Malen’s journey from an Arsenal academy prospect sold for £540,000 to a Premier League star drawing comparisons to Lionel Messi is nothing short of remarkable. His explosive performance against Burnley has thrust him into the spotlight, proving that Arsenal’s “discarded” talent has the potential to reach the very top. As Malen continues to dazzle at Aston Villa, the football world watches with bated breath, eager to see just how far this Dutch dynamo can go.