As the NFL’s 53-man roster deadline looms, the New England Patriots are navigating a pivotal moment in their quarterback depth chart. After releasing undrafted rookie Ben Wooldridge, who struggled in their final preseason game with 10 completions out of 20 attempts for 82 yards, a touchdown, and an interception, the Patriots are actively seeking a third quarterback for either their active roster or practice squad. The search has led them to an unexpected candidate: Tommy DeVito, the New York Giants’ quarterback who delivered a commanding performance against New England in their recent 42-10 preseason loss at MetLife Stadium.
DeVito, a 27-year-old New Jersey native, torched the Patriots’ defense, completing 17 of 20 passes for 198 yards and three touchdowns, earning a quarterback rating of 147.5. His near-flawless outing showcased his ability to read defenses and deliver precise throws under pressure, making him a standout in a game where New England’s secondary struggled to contain him. This performance may have been DeVito’s final act with the Giants, as their revamped quarterback room—featuring veteran signings Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston, alongside first-round draft pick Jaxson Dart—leaves little room for the former undrafted free agent.
The Giants’ crowded quarterback situation suggests DeVito could be traded or waived, especially since carrying four quarterbacks on the active roster is unlikely. ESPN’s Mike Reiss highlighted DeVito as a potential target for the Patriots, who need depth behind starter Drake Maye and backup Joshua Dobbs. DeVito’s stock has risen due to his proven ability to step up when called upon, most notably during his 2023 rookie season. That year, he unexpectedly led the Giants to a three-game winning streak, completing 72.2% of his passes without an interception and posting a passer rating above 100 in each victory, including a dramatic game-winning drive against the Green Bay Packers on Monday Night Football.
Despite his heroics, DeVito’s 2024 season was less inspiring, with a 5.8 yards-per-attempt average and no touchdowns in two starts, signaling he may not fit into the Giants’ long-term plans. However, his recent preseason dominance against New England underscores his potential as a reliable backup. For the Patriots, acquiring DeVito could provide insurance and a developmental prospect with NFL experience. His familiarity with high-pressure situations and his ability to win games—evidenced by his 3-3 record as a starter in 2023—make him an attractive option for a team looking to bolster its quarterback depth.
The irony of the situation is not lost on observers. DeVito, who dismantled New England’s defense in their preseason finale, could now join the very team he embarrassed. His local roots and fan-favorite status in New Jersey, where he earned the nickname “Tommy Cutlets” for his Italian heritage and charismatic personality, may not carry the same weight in Foxborough. Yet, his skill set—marked by a conservative, low-turnover style and the ability to manage games effectively—aligns well with the Patriots’ needs as they rebuild around a young roster.
As the roster cut deadline approaches, the Patriots face a critical decision. DeVito’s availability, whether via trade or waivers, presents an opportunity to add a quarterback who has already proven he can shine against them. If New England acts swiftly, they could turn a humbling preseason defeat into a strategic victory by securing a player who has shown he can compete at the NFL level. For DeVito, a move to the Patriots could offer a fresh start and a chance to continue his unlikely journey from undrafted rookie to NFL contributor.