Skip to main content

TIME’S UP! Unbelievable Pressure Mounts, Raiders Forced to Make a SHOCKING Decision About Their $75 Million Star

Posted on October 6, 2025 - 6:19 am by

A crushing 40-6 loss to the Indianapolis Colts has left Las Vegas Raiders fans reeling and pointing fingers at their first-year quarterback, Geno Smith. Just five games into his tenure with the Silver and Black, the 34-year-old signal-caller is under fire as the team stumbles to a dismal 1-4 record. The once-promising “Geno Smith experiment” is unraveling, and Raider Nation is demanding change—starting with benching their high-priced QB.

Colts fans better hope what Geno Smith just said in his presser is a lie
Colts fans better hope what Geno Smith just said in his presser is a lie

The Raiders’ four-game losing streak has ignited a firestorm of frustration, with fans zeroing in on Smith’s lackluster performance. Social media platforms, especially X, have become a battleground for fans voicing their discontent. One user didn’t mince words: “Geno Smith gotta be benched at this point.” Another slammed his decision-making, pointing to his league-high nine interceptions in just five weeks, including a costly throw into double coverage during the Colts debacle. “We seriously need to have a conversation about Geno Smith,” the fan fumed.

For many, the patience for Smith’s revival has run dry. “The Geno Smith era should be over in Vegas,” one fan declared, while another called the supposed quarterback renaissance “dead.” The sentiment is clear: five weeks of subpar play is more than enough for Raider Nation to demand a new direction.

The numbers paint an even bleaker picture. According to PFSN’s NFL QB Impact metric, Smith’s 74.1 grade entering Week 5 ranked him a lowly 24th among 37 qualifying quarterbacks—a figure likely to plummet further after the Colts rout. His Expected Points Added per Dropback (EPA/DB) of -0.07 places him 30th league-wide, marking his second-worst performance as a starter, only marginally better than his rocky 2013 rookie season with the Jets (-0.09).

Smith’s turnover woes are particularly glaring. His 5.5% interception rate, the second-worst in the NFL entering Week 5, puts him on track for a career-worst season in giveaways. Add to that his struggles under pressure—ranking 27th with an 8.9% sack rate, the highest of his career as a starter—and it’s no wonder fans are fed up.

“Geno Smith is not the answer, bench this guy,” one X user demanded, echoing the growing chorus. Another took aim at the Raiders’ official account: “Bench Geno @Raiders.” The frustration even spilled into visual protests, with one fan responding to the team’s final score post with a “We deserve better” graphic.

The Raiders’ investment in Smith is looking increasingly disastrous. Signed to a two-year, $75 million contract with a $40 million cap hit this season, Smith was expected to bring stability and leadership to a franchise desperate for a spark. Instead, his lackluster play has fans questioning whether the team can afford to keep him under center.

The pressure isn’t just on Smith—it’s on head coach Pete Carroll, too. Fans are calling for Carroll to set aside any loyalty to his former Seahawks quarterback. “Pete Carroll needs to swallow his pride and bench Geno Smith already,” one X user wrote. “I don’t care if Geno is ‘his guy,’ it’s clear he’s not the guy for this team. #RaiderNation.”

With the season slipping away and fan outrage at a boiling point, the Raiders face a critical decision. Can Smith turn things around, or is his time in Las Vegas already up? The team’s coaching staff must weigh the cost of sticking with their struggling $75 million star against the demands of a fanbase desperate for a win. As the losses mount and the criticism grows louder, one thing is certain: Raider Nation won’t stay quiet until something changes.