In a dramatic twist that has sent shockwaves through the football world, Arsenal and Manchester United are reportedly gearing up for a high-stakes battle to bring Scott McTominay back to the Premier League. The Scottish midfielder, who has been thriving at Napoli since his €30 million move from Old Trafford last summer, is now the subject of intense speculation as the 2026 transfer window approaches. However, any potential suitors will need to dig deep, with sources indicating that Napoli are holding out for an astronomical fee to part ways with their star performer.
McTominay’s transformation in Serie A has been nothing short of remarkable. Once viewed primarily as a tenacious box-to-box player during his time at Manchester United, the 28-year-old has elevated his game under Antonio Conte’s guidance at the Stadio Diego Armando Maradona. His relentless energy, dominant aerial presence, and knack for late runs into the box have made him a cornerstone of Napoli’s Scudetto push and Champions League campaign. This season alone, he has contributed eight goals and four assists, solidifying his status as one of Europe’s most complete midfielders.
Despite his success in Italy, whispers of a Premier League return have grown louder. Arsenal, under Mikel Arteta, see McTominay as the ideal addition to bolster their midfield depth and provide physicality in their pursuit of domestic and European glory. The Gunners have reportedly sounded out his representatives, drawn to his proven track record in England’s top flight and his ability to thrive in high-pressing systems.
Meanwhile, Manchester United’s interest adds a layer of nostalgia and intrigue. The club where McTominay spent over a decade, rising through the ranks at Carrington, is said to be considering a sensational reunion. With new manager Ruben Amorim looking to reshape the squad, McTominay’s familiarity with the club and his evolved skill set could make him a ‘game-changer’ for the Red Devils. Sources close to the player reveal that his “heart still beats for the Premier League,” but emphasize that any move must align perfectly with his ambitions – the right club, project, and role. “He’s not chasing a paycheck; he’s building a legacy,” one insider confided.
The race isn’t limited to these two giants, however. Tottenham Hotspur, who were first linked with an ambitious move back in October, remain in the mix, impressed by McTominay’s meteoric rise in Italy. Everton have also made preliminary approaches to his entourage, though talks of a record-breaking bid from the Toffees are premature at this stage. This multi-club interest underscores McTominay’s market value, but Napoli are in no rush to sell.
Club insiders in Naples have been unequivocal: it would take a “colossal” offer to even start negotiations. With Conte viewing McTominay as the linchpin of his 3-5-2 formation, any bid below €80 million (£70.5 million) would be dismissed outright. “We’re building something special here,” a source from the Partenopei hierarchy stated. “Scott’s thriving – why disrupt that?” McTominay himself has remained focused on his current commitments, expressing happiness at Napoli in recent interviews and prioritizing their European aspirations.
As the January window draws near, the Premier League’s siren call grows stronger, but Napoli’s fortress remains intact for now. For Arsenal or Manchester United to secure this blockbuster transfer, they’ll need more than just ambition – they’ll need wallets wide open. Only time will tell if this homecoming becomes reality, but one thing is clear: Scott McTominay’s story is far from over.