In a recent appearance on the “Speakeasy” talk show, Detroit Lions running back Jahmyr Gibbs didn’t hold back when asked to name his top five running backs in the NFL. With a nod to the elite, Gibbs rattled off his list: “Saquon, Derrick (Henry), right now, JT (Jonathan Taylor), I got David Montgomery.” But it was his choice of Philadelphia Eagles star Saquon Barkley as the undisputed number one that turned heads. For a rising star like Gibbs, who’s carving out his own legacy, to crown a rival as the league’s best? That’s not just respect—it’s a testament to Barkley’s unmatched dominance.
What makes Saquon Barkley the measuring stick for running backs? It’s not just the eye-popping stats—though he’s got those in spades, including a 2,000-yard rushing season and an Offensive Player of the Year award. Barkley’s game is a masterclass in versatility. His elite vision lets him slice through defenses like a hot knife through butter. His breakaway speed turns broken plays into highlight-reel gains. And his raw power? It’s the kind that leaves linebackers gasping and defenses second-guessing their game plan.
Barkley’s impact goes beyond the box score. He’s a dual-threat dynamo, equally dangerous catching passes out of the backfield as he is bulldozing through the line. In just three games this season, he’s racked up 194 yards and two touchdowns on 58 carries, averaging over 3.3 yards per attempt. Add in 10 receptions for 39 yards, and it’s clear why opponents lose sleep over him. Barkley doesn’t just play the game—he dictates it, forcing defenses to adjust coverages and opening up opportunities for his teammates.
Embed X: https://twitter.com/speakeasytlkshw/status/1971339158963843534
Gibbs, meanwhile, is no slouch. The Lions’ electrifying running back is coming off a breakout 2024 season, where he piled up 1,412 rushing yards and 16 touchdowns. This year, he’s kept the momentum going, with 43 carries for 180 yards and three scores through the first three games, plus 18 catches for 73 yards. His yards-per-carry may be slightly down, but his explosive quickness and receiving prowess make him a constant headache for defenses. Gibbs stretches the field in ways few others can, and at just 23 years old, he’s only scratching the surface of his potential.
Yet, in a moment of humility that speaks to his character, Gibbs didn’t put himself at the top of his list. Instead, he gave the crown to Barkley, a player whose all-around brilliance sets the bar for every running back in the league. It’s a rare move for a young star on the rise, but it shows Gibbs’ deep understanding of the game—and his respect for those who’ve mastered it.
Gibbs’ top-five list wasn’t just about Barkley. By including his Lions teammate David Montgomery alongside heavyweights like Derrick Henry and Jonathan Taylor, Gibbs highlighted the value of versatility and consistency. Montgomery, known for his relentless, hard-nosed running style, complements Gibbs perfectly in Detroit’s backfield. Henry brings thunderous power, while Taylor combines speed and finesse. Together, they represent the diverse skill sets that define today’s elite running backs. But Barkley? He’s the one who ties it all together—the complete package who can do it all.
Gibbs’ nod to Barkley isn’t just a tip of the cap—it’s a challenge to himself. At his current trajectory, Gibbs could soon join the elite tier he so admires. His ability to break off big runs, catch passes, and keep defenses guessing mirrors the qualities that make Barkley so special. If Gibbs continues to produce at this level, he might not just be making top-five lists—he could be topping them.
For now, though, Saquon Barkley remains the NFL’s gold standard, a player whose rare blend of power, agility, and receiving ability makes him a nightmare for any defense. And when a talent like Jahmyr Gibbs, who’s tearing up the league in his own right, calls you the best? That’s not just praise—it’s a coronation.