The Dallas Cowboys are entering the 2025 NFL season with significant changes, and one of the most intriguing storylines is the fierce competition at the running back position. With the arrival of three new faces—Jaydon Blue, Phil Mafah, and veteran addition Javonte Williams—the Cowboys’ backfield promises to be more explosive than ever. But who will emerge as the leader in the depth chart? Let’s dive into this unexpected battle.
Jaydon Blue: The Speedy Star with Big Ambitions
Jaydon Blue, selected by the Cowboys in the fifth round of the 2025 NFL Draft from the Texas Longhorns, is quickly becoming a focal point with his standout qualities. With blazing speed (4.38 seconds in the 40-yard dash at the NFL Combine) and versatile pass-catching ability, Blue is seen as a dynamic “weapon.” In his final season at Texas, he recorded 368 yards and six touchdowns on 42 receptions, showcasing his ability to contribute not only in the run game but also in the passing game.
What makes Blue a strong contender is the endorsement from team owner Jerry Jones himself. During a conversation at rookie camp, Jones expressed high expectations for Blue, hinting that he could take on a significant role as early as Week 1. Blue has boldly claimed he will win the 2025 NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year award, a lofty goal that isn’t entirely out of reach. However, with limited experience, can Blue outshine his more seasoned competitors to become the breakout star?
Phil Mafah: The Powerhouse from Clemson
Blue’s direct competitor is Phil Mafah, another rookie selected by the Cowboys in the seventh round from Clemson. With an imposing frame (6’1”, 234 pounds), Mafah brings strength and the ability to bulldoze through defensive lines. Unlike Blue, Mafah is likened to a “wrecking machine,” ideal for situations requiring power to gain crucial yards. While he lacks Blue’s explosive speed, Mafah compensates with durability and the ability to withstand physical punishment.
Mafah is expected to complement the Cowboys’ offense, particularly in short-yardage situations or near the goal line (red zone). However, as a late-round pick, he’ll need to work twice as hard to prove he can surpass his veteran teammates and Blue. Mafah’s competition isn’t just about skill but also about adapting quickly to the strategies of new head coach Brian Schottenheimer.
Javonte Williams: The Veteran Under Pressure to Prove Himself
Alongside the two rookies, Javonte Williams represents experience in this race. Williams, once a highly touted running back, joined the Cowboys hoping to rediscover his peak form. However, he faces significant pressure, with critics noting his lack of “explosiveness” compared to the younger rookies. With his prior NFL experience, Williams has an edge in tactical understanding and reading plays, but his speed and agility are under scrutiny.
Nevertheless, Williams remains a key piece in the Cowboys’ strategy, especially in short-pass situations. With the team building a versatile offense under Schottenheimer’s guidance, Williams has a chance to prove that experience trumps youth. However, if he fails to deliver a breakout performance, he risks being relegated to a backup role or even facing a potential roster cut before the season begins.
The Battle Under Brian Schottenheimer’s Lens
The presence of three running backs with distinct styles promises a thrilling competition during the Cowboys’ training camp. Head coach Brian Schottenheimer, who is working to establish a new team culture, is expected to prioritize a balanced offense that leverages strength, speed, and versatility. Blue may be the go-to choice for situations requiring speed and pass-catching, while Mafah excels in power-running scenarios. Williams, with his experience, could serve as a “bridge” in complex situations.
According to reports, Schottenheimer is fostering a healthy competitive environment within the team, incorporating activities like basketball shootouts and sharing personal motivations to build camaraderie. The running back battle is not only about skill but also about mental toughness and alignment with the team’s new philosophy.
Prediction: Who Will Take the Lead?
Currently, Jaydon Blue appears to have the edge, thanks to his speed, confidence, and Jerry Jones’ backing. However, Phil Mafah and Javonte Williams are far from easy opponents. With Schottenheimer’s potential emphasis on a run-and-pass offense (play-action), all three have opportunities to shine. Some projections suggest Blue could achieve 1,000 all-purpose yards in his rookie season, but that hinges on his ability to overcome challenges from his teammates.
This competition is not just about individual talent but also a testament to the Cowboys’ ambition to rebuild a stronger offense after a disappointing 2024 season. With quarterback Dak Prescott returning from injury and the addition of star wide receiver George Pickens, the running back unit will play a pivotal role in the Cowboys’ quest to return to the playoff race.
Conclusion
The battle among Jaydon Blue, Phil Mafah, and Javonte Williams is more than an internal competition—it’s a focal point for Dallas Cowboys fans. Each player brings a unique style, creating a diverse backfield for the team. Will Blue turn his bold prediction into reality, or will Mafah and Williams prove that experience and power are the deciding factors? Stay tuned for the next developments in training camp and the 2025 NFL season!